Pink Floyd 1939-??-??
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 8, Compilation, Unknown
Set 1
CD15
1 - Jokers Wild - Why Do Fools Fall in Love (uncredited)
2 - Jokers Wild - Walk like a Man (uncredited)
3 - Jokers Wild - Don't Ask Me (What I Say) (uncredited)
4 - Jokers Wild - Big Girls Don't Cry (uncredited)
5 - Jokers Wild - Beautiful Delilah (uncredited)
Recorded : 1965
Primary source : "Jokers Wild" mini LP, released 1965
Source for the tree : "Jokers Wild" RoIO CDR
Jokers Wild was a band formed during the mid-60s, featuring David Gilmour. The other
musicians were John Gordon (guitar), Clive Welham (drums), Tony Sainty (bass) and
David Altham (vocals). In 1965, they recorded a one-sided mini LP with these 5 songs.
Note that David Gilmour played in other bands before joining Jokers Wild: The
Newcomers (early 60s) and then The Ramblers (in 1962-1963).
6 - David Gilmour - There's No Way Out of Here (Baker) - stereo edit
Recorded : France, Superbear Studios, 1978
Primary source : "There's No Way Out of Here" UK single, released May 25, 1978
Source for the tree : "There's No Way Out of Here" US promo single
The second verse ("There are no answers here ...") and the second chorus ("There never
was there an answer ... without seeing") were deleted.
7 - David Gilmour - There's No Way Out of Here (Baker) - mono edit
Recorded : France, Superbear Studios, 1978
Primary source : "There's No Way Out of Here" US promo single, released August 19, 1978
Source for the tree : "There's No Way Out of Here" US promo single
Same edit as above: the second verse ("There are no answers here ...") and the second
chorus ("There never was there an answer ... without seeing") were deleted.
8 - David Gilmour - Like a Rolling Stone (Dylan)
Recorded : David Gilmour home studio, 1983
Primary source : BBC Radio One interview with David Gilmour, broadcast July 28, 1992
Source for the tree : "Solo Works Vol.2" RoIO
9 - David Gilmour - Blue Light (Gilmour) - edit
Recorded : Paris, Pathe-Marconi Studios, 1984
Primary source : "Blue Light" UK single, released February 13, 1984
Source for the tree : "Blue Light" US promo single
The instrumental part with percussion, just after the first chorus, is edited (4 bars instead
of 8). The organ solo (by Deep Purple's keyboardist Jon Lord) is edited (4 bars instead of
8).
10 - David Gilmour - Blue Light (Gilmour) - vocal version
Recorded : Paris, Pathe-Marconi Studios, 1984
Primary source : "Blue Light" 12" promo single, released 1984
Source for the tree : "Blue Light" 12" promo single
This is an extended and remixed version. The new mix is obvious, especially on
percussion, vocal lines and guitar effects. There are 8 guitar themes added just before
the first verse. After the organ solo, there's a new instrumental part with bass and
percussion. The final guitar solo is extended.
11 - David Gilmour - Blue Light (Gilmour) - instrumental version
Recorded : Paris, Pathe-Marconi Studios, 1984
Primary source : "Blue Light" 12" promo single, released 1984
Source for the tree : "Blue Light" 12" promo single
This is another extended version, almost totally instrumental (one can hear "she's a blue
light" somewhere though). The structure is completely different from the previous
extended version.
12 - Roger Waters - For the First Time Today (Waters) - parts 1 & 2
Recorded : Olympic, Eel Pie & the Billiard Room, February - December 1983
Primary source : "5.06 am (Every Strangers Eyes)" single, released June 1984
Source for the tree : "Selections from the Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" promo sampler
Part 1 and Part 2 are linked on this version, while there are in different places on the
album (with Part 2 on side one and Part 1 on side two!). The end of Part 2 fades early
(just at the beginning of the "stay with me" sequence).
13 - Roger Waters - 5.01 am (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking) (Waters) - extended 05:22
Recorded : Olympic, Eel Pie & the Billiard Room, February - December 1983
Primary source : "5.01 am (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking)" 12" single, released 1984
Source for the tree : "5.01 am (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking)" 12" single
There's an alternate guitar solo in the middle of the song, followed by a sax solo that isn't
on the album version. The last part with the repeated female vocal lines "these are the
pros and cons of hitchhiking" has 2 added lines (just after "oh babe, I must be dreaming
again"): the first one with a saxophone bit, the second one with a guitar bit. The
following lines are the same as on the album.
14 - Roger Waters - 5.06 am (Every Strangers Eyes) (Waters) - edit
Recorded : Olympic, Eel Pie & the Billiard Room, February - December 1983
Primary source : "5.06 am (Every Strangers Eyes)" single, released June 1984
Source for the tree : "Selections from the Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" promo sampler
On the album version, right at the beginning of the song, there are two guys that can be
heard in the background, asking to turn the Juke Box down. One of the two guys says
"hey, turn that f*** Juke Box down". This sentence was edited out on the single version.
15 - Roger Waters - Across the Universe (Lennon)
Recorded : London, BBC TV, December 5, 1985
Primary source : "Tribute to John Lennon" BBC TV show
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume One" RoIO CD
This version features Andy Fairweather-Low on guitar.
16 - Roger Waters - Radio K.A.O.S. - "loop message"
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." album, released 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio K.A.O.S." CD
The very end and the very start of "Radio K.A.O.S." have a sentence by Jim Ladd: "That's
... back to the beginning".
17 - Roger Waters - Radio Waves (Waters) - edit
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio Waves" single, released May 11, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
Shorter intro, without the words of Jim Ladd. Early fade out.
18- Roger Waters - Radio Waves (Waters) - extended
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio Waves" 12" single, released May 11, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
Jim Ladd's words at the very beginning were edited out. The intro has 4 more bars. An
instrumental part was added between the intro and the first verse (one instrumental
chorus, one instrumental verse and one chorus with female vocals, singing "radio").
Another instrumental part was added between the second chorus and the guitar solo
(with some voices, including a loud sentence "The Fish Report with a Beat, in stereo!").
The ending is different from the regular version: there's no fade out, it ends abruptly with
the words "in stereo".
19 - Roger Waters - Me or Him (Waters) - demo
Recorded : the Billiard Room, 1986
Primary source : Rockline interview, broadcast September 21, 1987
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume One" RoIO CD
This demo is close to the final version.
1 - Jokers Wild - Why Do Fools Fall in Love (uncredited)
2 - Jokers Wild - Walk like a Man (uncredited)
3 - Jokers Wild - Don't Ask Me (What I Say) (uncredited)
4 - Jokers Wild - Big Girls Don't Cry (uncredited)
5 - Jokers Wild - Beautiful Delilah (uncredited)
Recorded : 1965
Primary source : "Jokers Wild" mini LP, released 1965
Source for the tree : "Jokers Wild" RoIO CDR
Jokers Wild was a band formed during the mid-60s, featuring David Gilmour. The other
musicians were John Gordon (guitar), Clive Welham (drums), Tony Sainty (bass) and
David Altham (vocals). In 1965, they recorded a one-sided mini LP with these 5 songs.
Note that David Gilmour played in other bands before joining Jokers Wild: The
Newcomers (early 60s) and then The Ramblers (in 1962-1963).
6 - David Gilmour - There's No Way Out of Here (Baker) - stereo edit
Recorded : France, Superbear Studios, 1978
Primary source : "There's No Way Out of Here" UK single, released May 25, 1978
Source for the tree : "There's No Way Out of Here" US promo single
The second verse ("There are no answers here ...") and the second chorus ("There never
was there an answer ... without seeing") were deleted.
7 - David Gilmour - There's No Way Out of Here (Baker) - mono edit
Recorded : France, Superbear Studios, 1978
Primary source : "There's No Way Out of Here" US promo single, released August 19, 1978
Source for the tree : "There's No Way Out of Here" US promo single
Same edit as above: the second verse ("There are no answers here ...") and the second
chorus ("There never was there an answer ... without seeing") were deleted.
8 - David Gilmour - Like a Rolling Stone (Dylan)
Recorded : David Gilmour home studio, 1983
Primary source : BBC Radio One interview with David Gilmour, broadcast July 28, 1992
Source for the tree : "Solo Works Vol.2" RoIO
9 - David Gilmour - Blue Light (Gilmour) - edit
Recorded : Paris, Pathe-Marconi Studios, 1984
Primary source : "Blue Light" UK single, released February 13, 1984
Source for the tree : "Blue Light" US promo single
The instrumental part with percussion, just after the first chorus, is edited (4 bars instead
of 8). The organ solo (by Deep Purple's keyboardist Jon Lord) is edited (4 bars instead of
8).
10 - David Gilmour - Blue Light (Gilmour) - vocal version
Recorded : Paris, Pathe-Marconi Studios, 1984
Primary source : "Blue Light" 12" promo single, released 1984
Source for the tree : "Blue Light" 12" promo single
This is an extended and remixed version. The new mix is obvious, especially on
percussion, vocal lines and guitar effects. There are 8 guitar themes added just before
the first verse. After the organ solo, there's a new instrumental part with bass and
percussion. The final guitar solo is extended.
11 - David Gilmour - Blue Light (Gilmour) - instrumental version
Recorded : Paris, Pathe-Marconi Studios, 1984
Primary source : "Blue Light" 12" promo single, released 1984
Source for the tree : "Blue Light" 12" promo single
This is another extended version, almost totally instrumental (one can hear "she's a blue
light" somewhere though). The structure is completely different from the previous
extended version.
12 - Roger Waters - For the First Time Today (Waters) - parts 1 & 2
Recorded : Olympic, Eel Pie & the Billiard Room, February - December 1983
Primary source : "5.06 am (Every Strangers Eyes)" single, released June 1984
Source for the tree : "Selections from the Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" promo sampler
Part 1 and Part 2 are linked on this version, while there are in different places on the
album (with Part 2 on side one and Part 1 on side two!). The end of Part 2 fades early
(just at the beginning of the "stay with me" sequence).
13 - Roger Waters - 5.01 am (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking) (Waters) - extended 05:22
Recorded : Olympic, Eel Pie & the Billiard Room, February - December 1983
Primary source : "5.01 am (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking)" 12" single, released 1984
Source for the tree : "5.01 am (The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking)" 12" single
There's an alternate guitar solo in the middle of the song, followed by a sax solo that isn't
on the album version. The last part with the repeated female vocal lines "these are the
pros and cons of hitchhiking" has 2 added lines (just after "oh babe, I must be dreaming
again"): the first one with a saxophone bit, the second one with a guitar bit. The
following lines are the same as on the album.
14 - Roger Waters - 5.06 am (Every Strangers Eyes) (Waters) - edit
Recorded : Olympic, Eel Pie & the Billiard Room, February - December 1983
Primary source : "5.06 am (Every Strangers Eyes)" single, released June 1984
Source for the tree : "Selections from the Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" promo sampler
On the album version, right at the beginning of the song, there are two guys that can be
heard in the background, asking to turn the Juke Box down. One of the two guys says
"hey, turn that f*** Juke Box down". This sentence was edited out on the single version.
15 - Roger Waters - Across the Universe (Lennon)
Recorded : London, BBC TV, December 5, 1985
Primary source : "Tribute to John Lennon" BBC TV show
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume One" RoIO CD
This version features Andy Fairweather-Low on guitar.
16 - Roger Waters - Radio K.A.O.S. - "loop message"
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." album, released 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio K.A.O.S." CD
The very end and the very start of "Radio K.A.O.S." have a sentence by Jim Ladd: "That's
... back to the beginning".
17 - Roger Waters - Radio Waves (Waters) - edit
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio Waves" single, released May 11, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
Shorter intro, without the words of Jim Ladd. Early fade out.
18- Roger Waters - Radio Waves (Waters) - extended
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio Waves" 12" single, released May 11, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
Jim Ladd's words at the very beginning were edited out. The intro has 4 more bars. An
instrumental part was added between the intro and the first verse (one instrumental
chorus, one instrumental verse and one chorus with female vocals, singing "radio").
Another instrumental part was added between the second chorus and the guitar solo
(with some voices, including a loud sentence "The Fish Report with a Beat, in stereo!").
The ending is different from the regular version: there's no fade out, it ends abruptly with
the words "in stereo".
19 - Roger Waters - Me or Him (Waters) - demo
Recorded : the Billiard Room, 1986
Primary source : Rockline interview, broadcast September 21, 1987
Source for the tree : "Roger Waters - Rarities Volume One" RoIO CD
This demo is close to the final version.
Set 2
CD16
1 - Roger Waters - The Fish Report With A Beat
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." Video EP, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
2 - Roger Waters - 4 Minutes (Waters) - video edit
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." Video EP, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
The intro is different from the regular version: the noises are different, and the vocals
begin with the female vocals ("Sometimes I feel like going home"), while the first verse
sung by Waters alone was deleted ("After a near miss on the plane ..."). Applause was
included at the end.
3 - Roger Waters - The Tide Is Turning (After Live Aid) (Waters) - video edit
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." Video EP, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
The ending of the song is different (the choir section ends very early, without fading out
with the morse code as on the album).
4 - Roger Waters - Going to Live in L.A. (Waters)
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio Waves" single, released May 11, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
5 - Roger Waters - Back to Radio (Waters)
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "The Tide is Turning (After Live Aid)" 12" UK single, released November 16, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
6 - Roger Waters - Money (Waters) - 1987 version
Recorded : the Billiard Room, July 14, 1987
Primary source : "The Tide is Turning (After Live Aid)" UK single, released November 16, 1987
& "Sunset Strip" single, released 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
This is a "live in the studio" version, sung by Paul Carrack. Applauses were added in the
mix.
7 - Roger Waters - Molly's Song (Waters) - live
Recorded : live, Inglewood, The Forum, September 20, 1987
Primary source : "Who Needs Information" US single, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
This song was sung by backing vocalist Doreen Chanter, during the "Radio KA.O.S. Tour".
No studio version has surfaced, although it is said that Roger Waters and the Bleeding
Heart Band recorded it for the follow up to "Radio K.A.O.S." (that was never released).
However, a short extract from this song can be heard in the background during "Four
Minutes", on the "Radio K.A.O.S." album.
8 - Roger Waters - Another Brick in the Wall part 2 (Waters) - 1990 version
Recorded : June 1990
Primary source : "The Wall Berlin '90" US promo, released 1990
Source for the tree : "The Wall Berlin '90" US promo CD
Studio version, re-recorded by Roger Waters & the Bleeding Heart Band some weeks
before the Berlin concert. Note that some background noises and guitar effects were
directly taken from the song "Is There Anybody Out There?" (on "The Wall" album).
9 - Roger Waters - Another Brick in The Wall part 2 (Waters) - live edit
Recorded : live, Berlin, Potsdamer Platz, June 18-21, 1990
Primary source : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" UK single, released September 10, 1990
Source for the tree : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" CD single
Lead vocals by Cyndi Lauper. The 2nd guitar solo and the following keyboards solos were
edited out. The song ends differently: the two lines "All in all it's just another brick in the
wall" and "All and all you're just another brick in the wall" were added right after the
guitar solo, to end the song abruptly (instead of the music fade-out and teacher's
screams on the live album).
10 - Roger Waters - Young Lust (Waters, Gilmour) - live edit
Recorded : live, Berlin, Potsdamer Platz, June 18-21, 1990
Primary source : "Pieces from The Wall" UK promo, released 1990
Source for the tree : "Pieces from the Wall" UK promo CD
Lead vocals by Bryan Adams. The intro is shorter (the guitar/drums part has 2 bars
instead of 4). The keyboard solo (between the guitar solo and the last chorus) was edited
out.
11 - Roger Waters - Run Like Hell (Gilmour, Waters) - potsdamer mix
Recorded : 1990
Primary source : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" UK single, released September 10, 1990
Source for the tree : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" CD single
This is a completely new version, with new vocals by Roger Waters and a lot of dance
and beatbox rhythms. Some samples from the original guitar riffs and the "hunt" part
were used. The rest is almost keyboards only.
12 - Roger Waters - The Tide is Turning (Waters) - live edit
Recorded : live, Berlin, Potsdamer Platz, June 18-21, 1990
Primary source : "The Tide is Turning" UK single, released November 19, 1990
Source for the tree : "The Tide is Turning" US promo CD
On this version, all the instrumental tracks were re-recorded (there's no orchestra or
piano, and the guitar lines are different from those on the live album). Only the vocals
from the guests were kept (Roger re-recorded his own vocals). The chorus after the
second verse was edited, and the following instrumental part was edited out. The last
chorus (with "oh, oh, oh, the tide is turning" without drums) has 2 lines instead of 8. This
version fades out early.
13 - Roger Waters - What God Wants part 1 (Waters) - video edit
Recorded : 1992
Primary source : "What God Wants part 1" single, released August 24, 1992
Source for the tree : "What God Wants part 1" CD single
The intro is shorter: the first part with female vocals ("What God wants, Got gets, God'll
help us all") was edited out, and the lines "What God wants, God gets" (during the first
guitar solo) are sung only twice (instead of 3 times on the album version).
14 - Roger Waters - Perfect Sense - "backwards message"
Recorded : 1992
Primary source : "Amused to Death" album, released 1992
Source for the tree : "Amused to Death" CD
Roger Waters wanted to use some lines and "breathing effects" from Stanley Kubrick's
"2001 : A Space Odyssey", but Kubrick refused. This explains the backward message at
the beginning on "Perfect Sense": "Julia, however, in the light and visions of the issues of
Stanley, we changed our minds. We have decided to include a backward message.
Stanley, for you, and for all the other book partners... (screamed sentence)".
15 - Roger Waters - Three Wishes (Waters) - radio edit
Recorded : 1992
Primary source : "Three Wishes" UK single, released 1992
Source for the tree : "Three Wishes" UK CD single
The instrumental intro before the first verse was edited out. The long instrumental part,
between the last vocal lines and the ending guitar solo, was edited out.
16 - Marianne Maithfull - Incarceration of a Flower Child (Waters)
Recorded : Oxnard, the Teatro, July 1998
Primary source : "Vagabond Ways" Marianne Faithfull album, released June 14, 1999
Source for the tree : "Vagabond Ways" Marianne Faithfull CD
This is the song Roger Waters "offered" to Marianne Faithfull. It was composed during
the early Floyd days, in 1968. It begins with the words "Do you remember me, how we
used to be...", exactly the same words than those used by Waters in "Your Possible
Pasts", on "The Final Cut" album. Note that this song features Roger on bass synth.
1 - Roger Waters - The Fish Report With A Beat
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." Video EP, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
2 - Roger Waters - 4 Minutes (Waters) - video edit
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." Video EP, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
The intro is different from the regular version: the noises are different, and the vocals
begin with the female vocals ("Sometimes I feel like going home"), while the first verse
sung by Waters alone was deleted ("After a near miss on the plane ..."). Applause was
included at the end.
3 - Roger Waters - The Tide Is Turning (After Live Aid) (Waters) - video edit
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio K.A.O.S." Video EP, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
The ending of the song is different (the choir section ends very early, without fading out
with the morse code as on the album).
4 - Roger Waters - Going to Live in L.A. (Waters)
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "Radio Waves" single, released May 11, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
5 - Roger Waters - Back to Radio (Waters)
Recorded : the Billiard Room, October - December 1986
Primary source : "The Tide is Turning (After Live Aid)" 12" UK single, released November 16, 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
6 - Roger Waters - Money (Waters) - 1987 version
Recorded : the Billiard Room, July 14, 1987
Primary source : "The Tide is Turning (After Live Aid)" UK single, released November 16, 1987
& "Sunset Strip" single, released 1987
Source for the tree : "Radio KAOS off the Air" RoIO CDR
This is a "live in the studio" version, sung by Paul Carrack. Applauses were added in the
mix.
7 - Roger Waters - Molly's Song (Waters) - live
Recorded : live, Inglewood, The Forum, September 20, 1987
Primary source : "Who Needs Information" US single, released 1987
Source for the tree : "KAOS On The Road" RoIO CDR
This song was sung by backing vocalist Doreen Chanter, during the "Radio KA.O.S. Tour".
No studio version has surfaced, although it is said that Roger Waters and the Bleeding
Heart Band recorded it for the follow up to "Radio K.A.O.S." (that was never released).
However, a short extract from this song can be heard in the background during "Four
Minutes", on the "Radio K.A.O.S." album.
8 - Roger Waters - Another Brick in the Wall part 2 (Waters) - 1990 version
Recorded : June 1990
Primary source : "The Wall Berlin '90" US promo, released 1990
Source for the tree : "The Wall Berlin '90" US promo CD
Studio version, re-recorded by Roger Waters & the Bleeding Heart Band some weeks
before the Berlin concert. Note that some background noises and guitar effects were
directly taken from the song "Is There Anybody Out There?" (on "The Wall" album).
9 - Roger Waters - Another Brick in The Wall part 2 (Waters) - live edit
Recorded : live, Berlin, Potsdamer Platz, June 18-21, 1990
Primary source : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" UK single, released September 10, 1990
Source for the tree : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" CD single
Lead vocals by Cyndi Lauper. The 2nd guitar solo and the following keyboards solos were
edited out. The song ends differently: the two lines "All in all it's just another brick in the
wall" and "All and all you're just another brick in the wall" were added right after the
guitar solo, to end the song abruptly (instead of the music fade-out and teacher's
screams on the live album).
10 - Roger Waters - Young Lust (Waters, Gilmour) - live edit
Recorded : live, Berlin, Potsdamer Platz, June 18-21, 1990
Primary source : "Pieces from The Wall" UK promo, released 1990
Source for the tree : "Pieces from the Wall" UK promo CD
Lead vocals by Bryan Adams. The intro is shorter (the guitar/drums part has 2 bars
instead of 4). The keyboard solo (between the guitar solo and the last chorus) was edited
out.
11 - Roger Waters - Run Like Hell (Gilmour, Waters) - potsdamer mix
Recorded : 1990
Primary source : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" UK single, released September 10, 1990
Source for the tree : "Another Brick in the Wall part 2" CD single
This is a completely new version, with new vocals by Roger Waters and a lot of dance
and beatbox rhythms. Some samples from the original guitar riffs and the "hunt" part
were used. The rest is almost keyboards only.
12 - Roger Waters - The Tide is Turning (Waters) - live edit
Recorded : live, Berlin, Potsdamer Platz, June 18-21, 1990
Primary source : "The Tide is Turning" UK single, released November 19, 1990
Source for the tree : "The Tide is Turning" US promo CD
On this version, all the instrumental tracks were re-recorded (there's no orchestra or
piano, and the guitar lines are different from those on the live album). Only the vocals
from the guests were kept (Roger re-recorded his own vocals). The chorus after the
second verse was edited, and the following instrumental part was edited out. The last
chorus (with "oh, oh, oh, the tide is turning" without drums) has 2 lines instead of 8. This
version fades out early.
13 - Roger Waters - What God Wants part 1 (Waters) - video edit
Recorded : 1992
Primary source : "What God Wants part 1" single, released August 24, 1992
Source for the tree : "What God Wants part 1" CD single
The intro is shorter: the first part with female vocals ("What God wants, Got gets, God'll
help us all") was edited out, and the lines "What God wants, God gets" (during the first
guitar solo) are sung only twice (instead of 3 times on the album version).
14 - Roger Waters - Perfect Sense - "backwards message"
Recorded : 1992
Primary source : "Amused to Death" album, released 1992
Source for the tree : "Amused to Death" CD
Roger Waters wanted to use some lines and "breathing effects" from Stanley Kubrick's
"2001 : A Space Odyssey", but Kubrick refused. This explains the backward message at
the beginning on "Perfect Sense": "Julia, however, in the light and visions of the issues of
Stanley, we changed our minds. We have decided to include a backward message.
Stanley, for you, and for all the other book partners... (screamed sentence)".
15 - Roger Waters - Three Wishes (Waters) - radio edit
Recorded : 1992
Primary source : "Three Wishes" UK single, released 1992
Source for the tree : "Three Wishes" UK CD single
The instrumental intro before the first verse was edited out. The long instrumental part,
between the last vocal lines and the ending guitar solo, was edited out.
16 - Marianne Maithfull - Incarceration of a Flower Child (Waters)
Recorded : Oxnard, the Teatro, July 1998
Primary source : "Vagabond Ways" Marianne Faithfull album, released June 14, 1999
Source for the tree : "Vagabond Ways" Marianne Faithfull CD
This is the song Roger Waters "offered" to Marianne Faithfull. It was composed during
the early Floyd days, in 1968. It begins with the words "Do you remember me, how we
used to be...", exactly the same words than those used by Waters in "Your Possible
Pasts", on "The Final Cut" album. Note that this song features Roger on bass synth.
Set 3
Comment
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation
Volume 8 (CD15 - CD16): David Gilmour and Roger Waters Rarities
Volume 8 (CD15 - CD16): David Gilmour and Roger Waters Rarities
Sources
| SHNID | Date | Venue | City | State | Archive Identifier |
|---|
Created At
Wed Sep 08 2021 19:24:10 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Updated At
Wed Sep 08 2021 19:24:10 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Users with this performance
| Name | # | Active (0-5) | Top Collections | Last Update |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Michael D. | 4788 | 5 |
| 2024-7-14 |
| OldNeumanntapr | 8672 | 5 |
| 2024-9-15 |