Pink Floyd 1939-??-??
A Tree Full Of Secrets Volume 4, Compilation, Unknown
Set 1
CD7
1 - Learning to Fly (Gilmour, Ezrin, Carin, Moore) - demo
Recorded : 1986
Primary source : BBC Radio One interview with David Gilmour, broadcast July 28, 1992
Source for the tree : 3rd gen copy from BBC Radio One broadcast
This is Jon Carin's demo. Jon Carin met David Gilmour in 1985, during "Live Aid". He
played keyboards with the Floyd (in studio and on tour) from 1986 to 1994. He also
played keyboards, guitars and did some vocals on Roger Waters' "In The Flesh" Tour, in
1999 and 2000.
2 - Learning to Fly (Gilmour, Ezrin, Carin, Moore) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "Learning to Fly" US single, released September 15, 1987
Source for the tree : "Learning to Fly" UK CD single
The instrumental part before the last verse ("Above the planet on a wing and a prayer
...") is edited (6 bars instead of 10 during the "checklist"). This version also fades out
slightly earlier than the regular one.
3 - The Dogs of War (Gilmour, Moore) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "A Momentary Lapse of Reason Official Tour CD" US promo, released 1988
Source for the tree : "A Momentary Lapse of Reason Official Tour CD"
Shorter intro (2 themes instead of 8). Note that the end is not mixed with the beginning
of "One Slip" as on the album.
4 - One Slip (Gilmour, Manzanera) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "Learning to Fly" UK single, released October 3, 1987
Source for the tree : "Learning to Fly" UK CD single
This version begins with the first drum hit (the "clocks noises" part of the album version
is skipped). The rototom intro is edited (4 themes instead of 8) and doesn't have the
background keyboards. The central part with bass solo is edited (2 themes instead of 4).
The last chorus is repeated and the fade out happens during the second one (on the
album version, after the last chorus, there's a reprise of the bass solo and then the song
fades out).
5 - On the Turning Away (Gilmour, Moore) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "On the Turning Away" UK promo single, released December 7, 1987
Source for the tree : ?
The quiet fretless bass lines, just before the last verse, are edited out. The first part of
the final guitar solo is edited. Early fade out.
6 - The Dogs of War (Gilmour, Moore) - live
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "One Slip" single, released 1988
Source for the tree : "A Momentary Lapse of Reason Official Tour CD"
7 - On the Turning Away (Gilmour, Moore) - live
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "On the Turning Away" 12" single, released November 24, 1987
Source for the tree : "On the Turning Away" CD single
It was filmed and used for "On the Turning Away" video.
8 - One Slip (Gilmour, Manzanera) - live 05:24
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "One Slip" video
Source for the tree : "One Slip" video
Note that this live version was never officially released. It's only available from TV
broadcasts.
9 - Run Like Hell (Waters, Gilmour) - live
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "On the Turning Away" single, released November 24, 1987
Source for the tree : "On the Turning Away" CD single
10 - Wearing the Inside Out (Wright, Moore) - LP version
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "The Division Bell" LP, released March 30, 1994
Source for the tree : "The Division Bell" LP
This LP version is different from the CD version, with a slight change in the lyrics: the
first lines of the second verse ("I murmured a vow ... when I think aloud") were added to
the first verse, and the rest of the second verse ("Extinguished by the light ... with an
empty smile") was left out, so that the LP version has a longer first verse, and no second
verse between "This bleeding heart's not beating much" and "I'm creeping back to life...".
11 - Take it Back (Gilmour, Ezrin, Samson, Laird-Clowes) - edit
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" single, released May 16, 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" CD single
Edits during the intro (5 chords instead of 9), the central part (8 chords instead of 16)
and the outro (4 chords instead of 8).
12 - Take it Back (Gilmour, Ezrin, Samson, Laird-Clowes) - extended
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" French promo single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" French promo single, released 1994
Extended ending.
13 - Keep Talking (Gilmour, Wright, Samson) - radio edit
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK single, released October 17, 1994
Source for the tree : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK CD single
Late fade in (the first 24 seconds from the original version are missing). The guitar and
keyboards solos in the middle of the song are both shortened. Early fade out.
1 - Learning to Fly (Gilmour, Ezrin, Carin, Moore) - demo
Recorded : 1986
Primary source : BBC Radio One interview with David Gilmour, broadcast July 28, 1992
Source for the tree : 3rd gen copy from BBC Radio One broadcast
This is Jon Carin's demo. Jon Carin met David Gilmour in 1985, during "Live Aid". He
played keyboards with the Floyd (in studio and on tour) from 1986 to 1994. He also
played keyboards, guitars and did some vocals on Roger Waters' "In The Flesh" Tour, in
1999 and 2000.
2 - Learning to Fly (Gilmour, Ezrin, Carin, Moore) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "Learning to Fly" US single, released September 15, 1987
Source for the tree : "Learning to Fly" UK CD single
The instrumental part before the last verse ("Above the planet on a wing and a prayer
...") is edited (6 bars instead of 10 during the "checklist"). This version also fades out
slightly earlier than the regular one.
3 - The Dogs of War (Gilmour, Moore) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "A Momentary Lapse of Reason Official Tour CD" US promo, released 1988
Source for the tree : "A Momentary Lapse of Reason Official Tour CD"
Shorter intro (2 themes instead of 8). Note that the end is not mixed with the beginning
of "One Slip" as on the album.
4 - One Slip (Gilmour, Manzanera) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "Learning to Fly" UK single, released October 3, 1987
Source for the tree : "Learning to Fly" UK CD single
This version begins with the first drum hit (the "clocks noises" part of the album version
is skipped). The rototom intro is edited (4 themes instead of 8) and doesn't have the
background keyboards. The central part with bass solo is edited (2 themes instead of 4).
The last chorus is repeated and the fade out happens during the second one (on the
album version, after the last chorus, there's a reprise of the bass solo and then the song
fades out).
5 - On the Turning Away (Gilmour, Moore) - edit
Recorded : 1987
Primary source : "On the Turning Away" UK promo single, released December 7, 1987
Source for the tree : ?
The quiet fretless bass lines, just before the last verse, are edited out. The first part of
the final guitar solo is edited. Early fade out.
6 - The Dogs of War (Gilmour, Moore) - live
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "One Slip" single, released 1988
Source for the tree : "A Momentary Lapse of Reason Official Tour CD"
7 - On the Turning Away (Gilmour, Moore) - live
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "On the Turning Away" 12" single, released November 24, 1987
Source for the tree : "On the Turning Away" CD single
It was filmed and used for "On the Turning Away" video.
8 - One Slip (Gilmour, Manzanera) - live 05:24
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "One Slip" video
Source for the tree : "One Slip" video
Note that this live version was never officially released. It's only available from TV
broadcasts.
9 - Run Like Hell (Waters, Gilmour) - live
Recorded : live, Atlanta, the Omni, November 5, 1987
Primary source : "On the Turning Away" single, released November 24, 1987
Source for the tree : "On the Turning Away" CD single
10 - Wearing the Inside Out (Wright, Moore) - LP version
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "The Division Bell" LP, released March 30, 1994
Source for the tree : "The Division Bell" LP
This LP version is different from the CD version, with a slight change in the lyrics: the
first lines of the second verse ("I murmured a vow ... when I think aloud") were added to
the first verse, and the rest of the second verse ("Extinguished by the light ... with an
empty smile") was left out, so that the LP version has a longer first verse, and no second
verse between "This bleeding heart's not beating much" and "I'm creeping back to life...".
11 - Take it Back (Gilmour, Ezrin, Samson, Laird-Clowes) - edit
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" single, released May 16, 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" CD single
Edits during the intro (5 chords instead of 9), the central part (8 chords instead of 16)
and the outro (4 chords instead of 8).
12 - Take it Back (Gilmour, Ezrin, Samson, Laird-Clowes) - extended
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" French promo single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" French promo single, released 1994
Extended ending.
13 - Keep Talking (Gilmour, Wright, Samson) - radio edit
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK single, released October 17, 1994
Source for the tree : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK CD single
Late fade in (the first 24 seconds from the original version are missing). The guitar and
keyboards solos in the middle of the song are both shortened. Early fade out.
Set 2
CD8
1 - Lost for Words (Gilmour, Samson) - clean version
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "Lost for Words" US promo single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "Lost for Words" US promo CD
The "f***" word in "please gonna f*** myself" is censored by a "beep". Early fade out.
2 - High Hopes (Gilmour, Samson) - radio edit
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK single, released October 17, 1994
Source for the tree : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK CD single
Edits during the piano/bells intro (2 themes instead of 4), during the central instrumental
part with acoustic guitar (2 themes instead of 4) and during the ending guitar solo. Note
that the "radio edit" on the French single is 5 seconds shorter (2 more bells ringings were
cut).
3 - High Hopes - "phone call"
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "The Division Bell" album, released March 30, 1994
Source for the tree : "The Division Bell" CD
At the very end of "The Division Bell" album, there's a phone conversation between Steve
O'Rourke (Floyd's manager) and Charlie (Polly Samson's son; Polly married David Gilmour
in 1994). This conversation was probably incidentally recorded by the answering machine
at Gilmour's house.
4 - David Gilmour interview
Recorded : March 26, 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" Australian promo single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" Australian promo CD
This is an "answers only" interview, where David Gilmour is supposed to answer 8
different questions. The questions are available on a separate sheet provided with the
promo CD:
Question 1: Where was your new album, The Division Bell, recorded ?
Question 2: How was the recording of this album different from the previous Pink Floyd
album ?
Question 3: How did you arrive at the title The Division Bell ?
Question 4: Do you enjoy putting on such enormous concert events ?
Question 5: Let's talk about the songs on the album. On "What Do You Want From Me"
the music was written by you and Richard and the lyrics were written by you
and Polly Samson. Could you tell us how this wame about ?
Question 6: There's an incredible instrumental on the album. Could you explain how you
came up with the music and the title to "Marooned" ?
Question 7: How did you come up with "Wearing The Inside Out". I see that Dick Parry
plays saxophone on this song ?
Question 8: "Keep Talking" is an amazing song. It's being played on the radio almost
constantly. Are you happy with the response that song is getting ?
5 - Soundscape (uncredited)
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette, released 1995
Source for the tree : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette
This track consists of various ambient noises and is probably an extract of the (longer)
tape that was played before the Floyd shows during the Division Bell Tour. Somewhere in
the middle, an extract from "Cluster One" can be heard. It is not available on
"P*U*L*S*E" CD and LP releases.
6 - Astronomy DominÈ (Barrett) - live
Recorded : live, Miami, Joe Robbie Stadium, April 30, 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" single, released May 16, 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" CD single
First song from the first night of the Division Bell Tour.
7 - One of These Days (Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour) - live
Recorded : live, Hannover, Niedersachsenstadion, August 17, 1994
Primary source : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK CD single
8 - Wish You Were Here (Waters, Gilmour) - live edit
Recorded : live, Rome, Cinecitta, September 20, 1994
Primary source : "Wish You Were Here" French promo single, released 1995
Source for the tree : "Wish You Were Here" French promo CD
This is an edit of the "P*U*L*S*E" version: it fades in at the beginning of the acoustic
guitar solo (at 01:42 on "P*U*L*S*E" CD), and there's a short edit during the last
guitar/voice duo, after the last verse (the segment 04:29-04:43 on the "P*U*L*S*E" CD
version was cut).
9 - Coming Back to Life (Gilmour) - live edit
Recorded : live, London, Earls Court, October 13, 1994
Primary source : "Coming Back to Life" US promo single, released 1995
Source for the tree : "Coming Back to Life" US promo CD
This is an edit of the "P*U*L*S*E" version: the instrumental guitar intro is missing (the
song begins with the first lines "Where were you ..."), and it ends just after the last verse
(skipping the final guitar solo).
10 - One of These Days (Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour) - live
Recorded : live, London, Earls Court, October 16 & 20, 1994
Primary source : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette, released 1995
Source for the tree : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette
This is not the same live version as the one available on "High Hopes / Keep Talking"
single. It's available on "P*U*L*S*E" cassette and LP releases only.
1 - Lost for Words (Gilmour, Samson) - clean version
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "Lost for Words" US promo single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "Lost for Words" US promo CD
The "f***" word in "please gonna f*** myself" is censored by a "beep". Early fade out.
2 - High Hopes (Gilmour, Samson) - radio edit
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK single, released October 17, 1994
Source for the tree : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK CD single
Edits during the piano/bells intro (2 themes instead of 4), during the central instrumental
part with acoustic guitar (2 themes instead of 4) and during the ending guitar solo. Note
that the "radio edit" on the French single is 5 seconds shorter (2 more bells ringings were
cut).
3 - High Hopes - "phone call"
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "The Division Bell" album, released March 30, 1994
Source for the tree : "The Division Bell" CD
At the very end of "The Division Bell" album, there's a phone conversation between Steve
O'Rourke (Floyd's manager) and Charlie (Polly Samson's son; Polly married David Gilmour
in 1994). This conversation was probably incidentally recorded by the answering machine
at Gilmour's house.
4 - David Gilmour interview
Recorded : March 26, 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" Australian promo single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" Australian promo CD
This is an "answers only" interview, where David Gilmour is supposed to answer 8
different questions. The questions are available on a separate sheet provided with the
promo CD:
Question 1: Where was your new album, The Division Bell, recorded ?
Question 2: How was the recording of this album different from the previous Pink Floyd
album ?
Question 3: How did you arrive at the title The Division Bell ?
Question 4: Do you enjoy putting on such enormous concert events ?
Question 5: Let's talk about the songs on the album. On "What Do You Want From Me"
the music was written by you and Richard and the lyrics were written by you
and Polly Samson. Could you tell us how this wame about ?
Question 6: There's an incredible instrumental on the album. Could you explain how you
came up with the music and the title to "Marooned" ?
Question 7: How did you come up with "Wearing The Inside Out". I see that Dick Parry
plays saxophone on this song ?
Question 8: "Keep Talking" is an amazing song. It's being played on the radio almost
constantly. Are you happy with the response that song is getting ?
5 - Soundscape (uncredited)
Recorded : 1994
Primary source : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette, released 1995
Source for the tree : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette
This track consists of various ambient noises and is probably an extract of the (longer)
tape that was played before the Floyd shows during the Division Bell Tour. Somewhere in
the middle, an extract from "Cluster One" can be heard. It is not available on
"P*U*L*S*E" CD and LP releases.
6 - Astronomy DominÈ (Barrett) - live
Recorded : live, Miami, Joe Robbie Stadium, April 30, 1994
Primary source : "Take it Back" single, released May 16, 1994
Source for the tree : "Take it Back" CD single
First song from the first night of the Division Bell Tour.
7 - One of These Days (Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour) - live
Recorded : live, Hannover, Niedersachsenstadion, August 17, 1994
Primary source : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK single, released 1994
Source for the tree : "High Hopes / Keep Talking" UK CD single
8 - Wish You Were Here (Waters, Gilmour) - live edit
Recorded : live, Rome, Cinecitta, September 20, 1994
Primary source : "Wish You Were Here" French promo single, released 1995
Source for the tree : "Wish You Were Here" French promo CD
This is an edit of the "P*U*L*S*E" version: it fades in at the beginning of the acoustic
guitar solo (at 01:42 on "P*U*L*S*E" CD), and there's a short edit during the last
guitar/voice duo, after the last verse (the segment 04:29-04:43 on the "P*U*L*S*E" CD
version was cut).
9 - Coming Back to Life (Gilmour) - live edit
Recorded : live, London, Earls Court, October 13, 1994
Primary source : "Coming Back to Life" US promo single, released 1995
Source for the tree : "Coming Back to Life" US promo CD
This is an edit of the "P*U*L*S*E" version: the instrumental guitar intro is missing (the
song begins with the first lines "Where were you ..."), and it ends just after the last verse
(skipping the final guitar solo).
10 - One of These Days (Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour) - live
Recorded : live, London, Earls Court, October 16 & 20, 1994
Primary source : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette, released 1995
Source for the tree : "P*U*L*S*E" cassette
This is not the same live version as the one available on "High Hopes / Keep Talking"
single. It's available on "P*U*L*S*E" cassette and LP releases only.
Set 3
Comment
The Definitive Pink Floyd Rarities Compilation
Volume 4 (CD7 - CD8): Pink Floyd Rarities 1987 - 1994
Volume 4 (CD7 - CD8): Pink Floyd Rarities 1987 - 1994
Sources
| SHNID | Date | Venue | City | State | Archive Identifier |
|---|
Created At
Wed Sep 08 2021 13:39:41 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Updated At
Wed Sep 08 2021 13:39:41 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Users with this performance
| Name | # | Active (0-5) | Top Collections | Last Update |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Michael D. | 4788 | 5 |
| 2024-7-14 |
| OldNeumanntapr | 8672 | 5 |
| 2024-9-15 |